Nick O'Leary is a straight bass player in a queercore band that is searching for a name but tentatively calls themselves The Jerk-Offs. A teenager from Hoboken, New Jersey, he is still heartbroken after his girlfriend, Tris, broke up with him three weeks, two days, and 23 hours ago and continues to make “breakup” mixtapes for her. Thom and Dev, his gay bandmates who both hate Tris, convince Nick to perform at a club because his favorite band—the legendary, publicity-shy Independent music band Where’s Fluffy? —is performing somewhere in New York City that night.