Crumply Crumplestein sits in a chair where he hosts 'Unbelievable Tales' and introduces a short 'Unbelievable Story'. The story follows two kids who play in the river until one of the dies. Crumply leaves the show seriously disturbed. He returns home where he stresses about two kidnapped children. He kills the two of them carving off their faces. The next story features a man playing yo-yo who stabs a child.