Dr. Peter Newmans (Johnny Simmons) is a 27 year old Sex therapy who lives a quiet life alone, silently crushing on his pretty neighbour, Michelle (Brittany Snow). He is known for being a very non-sexual person, comically because he wrote a book about how sex is not a necessity. Michelle breaks up with her workaholic boyfriend, and Peter uses this time to comfort her. Michelle, feeling vulnerable, kisses Peter. He lies and says he has a headache in order to get out of the situation. Feeling like a freak because he doesn't feel attraction to women in the way other men are, he heads back to his apartment.