With her own successful business, and a full-grown daughter, single mother Olivia Persching is looking forward to her upcoming nuptials to successful New York realtor Josh Johnson. At her daughter Grace's suggestion, Olivia books a picturesque New England Inn for her wedding. She is shocked to discover that the inn is owned and run by her college sweetheart Mick Turner, and even more dismayed when she learns that Mick will be the singer at her wedding, after her previously booked band cancels at the last moment. The pair haven't seen each other for over two decades, and parted on bad terms. Olivia and Mick's reunion is plagued by animosity, however that soon fades as old feelings resurface, encouraged by both Grace and Mick's teenage daughter Julie. Mick confesses his true feelings to Olivia at the rehearsal dinner, and she is left with the choice between going ahead with the wedding as planned or taking a second chance on first love.